| 2020 | Lane Herbert | Greenhill School | Northwestern University | |
| 2019 | Kaedric Cobbs | John H. Guyer | University of Texas-San Antonio | |
| 2018 | Hannah Mandell | Frisco Wakeland | Pomona College | |
| 2017 | Mikayla Wilson | Trimble Tech | Texas Christian University | |
| 2016 | Anna Connolly | J.J. Pearce | Emory University | |
| 2015 | Raymar Turangan | The Colony | Vanderbilt University | |
| 2014 | Christine Vonder Haar | R.L. Paschal | Massachusetts Institute of Technology | |
| 2013 | Eric Yang | The Colony | Harvard University | |
| 2012 | Elizabeth Crowling | Hillcrest | Texas A&M University | Texas A&M University College of Veterinary Medicine & Biomedical Sciences |
| 2011 | Will Squiers | Cistercian Preparatory School | Princeton University | Dell Medical School at University of Texas |
| 2010 | Hillary Rosenjack Zimmick | Grapevine | Vanderbilt University | Stanford University Graduate School of Business |
| 2009 | Aaron Chang | Lamar | Johns Hopkins University | |
| 2008 | Taylor Breen | South Hills | Columbia University | |
| 2007 | Jack Squiers | Cistercian Preparatory School | Princeton University | University of Texas Southwestern Medical School |
| 2006 | Rhodes Coffey | Science & Engineering Magnet School & Woodrow Wilson | Rice University | |
| 2005 | Kate Doherty | Bishop Lynch | Vanderbilt University | Vanderbilt University School of Medicine |
| 2004 | Sharon Chang Reale | R.L. Paschal | Washington University | University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine |
| 2003 | Elizabeth Pratt | Fort Worth Country Day School | Stanford University | UCLA Anderson School |
| 2002 | Brent Oglesby | Woodrow Wilson | United States Naval Academy | |
| 2001 | Jeff Miller | Jesuit College Preparatory School | Princeton University | University of Oxford |
| 2000 | Taylor Keep | Lake Highlands | Stanford University | University of California-Berkeley |
| 1999 | Amanda Henkes | L.D. Bell | Southern Methodist University | Texas A&M University |
| 1998 | Jamie Walker Erwin | R.L. Paschal | University of Arkansas | University of Texas Southwestern Medical School |
| 1997 | Emily Peters Crouse | Southwest | University of Texas | |
| 1996 | Bryan Bailey | Trinity | United States Air Force Academy | |
| 1995 | Robert Schoenvogel | Cistercian Preparatory School | University of Virginia | Darden School of Business |
| 1994 | Lindsey Leininger | J.J. Pearce | Princeton University | Northeastern University & University of Chicago |
| 1993 | Stephen Garrison | Eastern Hills | Stanford University | Harvard Business School |
| 1992 | Holland Gary | Greenhill School | Princeton University | Wharton School of Business |
| 1991 | Field Scovell | Hillcrest | Texas Tech University | Texas Tech University School of Medicine |
| 1990 | Erin Henderson Gasch | Woodrow Wilson | Duke University | Fuqua School of Business |
| 1989 | Stoney Pryor | Lake Highlands | Texas A&M University | Sam Houston State University |
| 1988 | Allison Campfield Taten | The Hockaday School | Stanford University | University of Texas Southwestern Medical School |
| 1987 | James Falconer | Lamar | Trinity University | Baylor College of Medicine & Emory University School of Medicine |
| 1986 | Joel Sharp | Jesuit College Preparatory School | Princeton University | SMU Dedman School of Law |
